Skip to content
Home » Title: Battle of the Trowels: Marshalltown vs W. Rose

Title: Battle of the Trowels: Marshalltown vs W. Rose

marshalltown bricklaying trowel

Title: Battle of the Trowels: Marshalltown vs W. Rose


When it comes to bricklaying, the choice of tools can make all the difference between a job well done and a frustrating experience. The trusty trowel is among the most essential tools in a bricklayer’s arsenal. In this comparison post, I’ll delve into the age-old debate: Marshalltown versus W. Rose. We’ll explore the history of each company, the pros and cons to find the best trowel, and finally, crown a winner.


  • History: Founded in 1890 in Marshalltown, Iowa, Marshalltown Company has been a stalwart in the construction tools industry for over a century. With a rich history of innovation and quality craftsmanship, Marshalltown has earned a reputation as a trusted brand among professionals worldwide.
  • Pros:
    • Durability: Marshalltown trowels are known for their sturdy construction and are made from high-quality materials that ensure longevity.
    • Variety: Marshalltown offers a wide range of trowel options, catering to different preferences and needs of bricklayers.
    • Ergonomics: Many users appreciate the comfortable grip and balanced design of Marshalltown trowels, reducing strain during long hours of use.
  • Cons:
    • Price: Marshalltown trowels tend to be slightly pricier than some other brands.
    • Availability: Depending on your location, Marshalltown products might not be as readily available as other brands.

W. Rose:

  • History: Established in 1798, W. Rose has a history that spans more than two centuries. Based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, W. Rose has built a legacy of craftsmanship and quality, earning the trust of generations of masons and bricklayers.
  • Pros:
    • Tradition: W. Rose trowels embody a tradition of excellence passed down through generations of craftsmen.
    • Performance: Many users swear by the superior performance of W. Rose trowels, particularly in precision and control.
    • Heritage: For bricklayers who value heritage and tradition, W. Rose trowels are uniquely appealing.
  • Cons:
    • Limited Selection: Compared to other brands, W. Rose may offer a more limited range of trowel options.
    • Learning Curve: Due to their unique design and feel, some users may find W. Rose trowels require a bit of a learning curve.

The Bricklayer’s Preference:

While opinions vary among bricklayers, many lean towards Marshalltown for its durability, versatility, and ergonomic design. Marshalltown’s wide range of trowel options allows bricklayers to find the perfect fit for their needs and preferences. Additionally, Marshalltown’s commitment to quality and innovation ensures that professionals can trust their tools to perform reliably daily.

And the Winner Is… Marshalltown:

Marshalltown emerges as the clear winner in the showdown between Marshalltown and W. Rose. With its century-long legacy of excellence, unmatched durability, and ergonomic design, Marshalltown trowels are the go-to choice for discerning bricklayers worldwide. Whether you’re a seasoned professional or a novice apprentice, investing in a Marshalltown trowel is a decision you won’t regret. Join the legions of satisfied bricklayers who swear by Marshalltown and experience the difference for yourself.

In conclusion, regarding bricklayers’ trowels, Marshalltown reigns supreme. Choose Marshalltown and elevate your bricklaying game to new heights of precision, efficiency, and satisfaction.

marshalltown bricklaying trowel

W. Rose: A Close Second

While Marshalltown takes the crown, it’s essential to acknowledge why W. Rose remains a formidable contender in bricklayers’ trowels: W. Rose’s centuries-old heritage and dedication to craftsmanship position it as a close second in this comparison.

Why W. Rose is a Superior Trowel for Many:

  1. Precision Engineering: W. Rose trowels are renowned for their precision engineering, allowing unparalleled control and accuracy in bricklaying and masonry tasks.
  2. Timeless Tradition: W. Rose embodies a timeless tradition of excellence that resonates with bricklayers who value heritage and craftsmanship. The brand’s long history and commitment to quality craftsmanship evoke a sense of pride and trust among users.
  3. Superior Performance: Many bricklayers swear by the exceptional performance of W. Rose trowels, citing their ability to deliver consistent results even in the most demanding conditions. From novice masons to seasoned professionals, W. Rose trowels are prized for their reliability, superior blade and performance.
  4. Legacy of Innovation: Despite its traditional roots, W. Rose continues to innovate, incorporating modern technologies and materials to enhance the performance and durability of its trowels. This commitment to innovation ensures that W. Rose remains relevant in an ever-evolving industry.
w.rose bricklaying trowel

Why Marshalltown Edges Out as the Ultimate Choice:

While W. Rose offers undeniable craftsmanship and performance, Marshalltown ultimately edges out as the ultimate choice for bricklayers’ trowels. Marshalltown’s extensive range of options, unmatched durability, and ergonomic design set it apart as the preferred brand for professionals worldwide. Additionally, Marshalltown’s widespread availability and reputation for consistency further solidify its position as the top choice among bricklayers.

Ultimately, whether you opt for the timeless tradition of W. Rose or the innovative excellence of Marshalltown, both brands offer quality trowels that can withstand the rigours of bricklaying. However, for those seeking a versatile, durable, and ergonomic trowel that delivers consistent performance, Marshalltown stands tall as the undisputed champion of bricklayers’ trowels.

Marshalltown Trowel Options:

Philadelphia Pattern Brick Trowel: This classic trowel features a wide, flat blade with a slight taper towards the front. It’s designed for general bricklaying tasks and offers a good balance between manoeuvrability and mortar capacity.

marshalltown philidelphia bricklayers trowel

London Pattern Brick Trowel: Similar to the Philadelphia pattern, the London pattern trowel has a slightly more pronounced taper towards the front, allowing for more precise mortar application. It’s favoured by bricklayers who require extra control and accuracy.

Wide London Pattern Brick Trowel: As the name suggests, this trowel has a broader blade than the standard London pattern. It’s ideal for laying more giant bricks or blocks and increases surface area for spreading mortar.

marshalltown wide london trowel

Pointing Trowel: This small, triangular trowel is designed to tell and finish brickwork joints. Its narrow blade allows for precise control when filling in mortar joints.

Margin Trowel: The margin trowel has a rectangular blade and is primarily used for spreading and shaping mortar in tight spaces, such as corners or around obstructions.

W. Rose Trowel Options:

Philadelphia Pattern Brick Trowel: W. Rose offers a traditional Philadelphia pattern brick trowel with a wide, flat blade and a taper towards the front. It’s suitable for general bricklaying tasks and provides a good balance between versatility and mortar capacity.

w rose cork handle Philadelphia brick trowel

London Pattern Brick Trowel: Similarly to Marshalltown, W. Rose provides a London pattern brick trowel with a slightly more pronounced taper towards the front for enhanced control and precision.

Wide London Pattern Brick Trowel: W. Rose offers a wide London pattern trowel, similar to Marshalltown’s, with a broader blade for laying larger bricks or blocks.

wrose london

Pointing Trowel: W. Rose’s pointing trowel features a narrow, triangular blade explicitly designed for pointing and finishing mortar joints.

Comparison of Design and Functionality:

Both Marshalltown and W. Rose offer similar trowel options, including the Philadelphia pattern, London pattern, wide London pattern, and pointing trowels. In terms of design, the trowels from both brands feature high-quality construction with durable blades and comfortable handles.

However, subtle differences in design and functionality may exist between the two brands’ trowels. For instance, the handle shapes and materials used may vary slightly, affecting the overall feel and grip of the trowel. Additionally, while both brands prioritize durability and performance, users may have personal preferences based on the feel and balance of the trowel in hand.

Ultimately, the choice between Marshalltown and W. Rose trowels may come down to individual preferences, such as handle ergonomics, brand loyalty, or specific features each brand offers. Both brands are renowned for their quality craftsmanship and are trusted by professionals in the construction industry worldwide.

Best Bricklaying Trowel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *